Q12 of 13 Page 1

Answer ANY ONE the following in 100-120 words.

(A) Natalya and Ivan argued about the ownership of Oxen Meadows and the superiority of their respective dogs in the play, The Proposal.


Imagine yourself as the playwright of the play. Based on your understanding of the personality traits of Natalya and Ivan, write a dialogue based on an imaginary event, showcasing another argument between them.


OR


(B) Read the extracts given below and comment on the difference in the nature of help both the characters, of these two stories, received.


a) Suddenly I came out of the clouds and saw two straight lines of lights in front of me. It was a runway! An airport! I was safe! I turned to look for my friend in the black aeroplane but the sky was empty. [The Black Aeroplane]


b) All through the night Lencho thought only of his one hope: the help of God…The fol- lowing Sunday, at daybreak he began to write a letter…It was nothing less than a let- ter to God...The following Sunday Lencho came a bit earlier than usual to ask if there was a letter for him…. Lencho showed not the slightest surprise on seeing the mon- ey, such was his confidence. [A Letter to God]


Natalya: Your dog may be superior than mine but what it adorns is surely of the most inferior quality.


Ivan: Don’t you dare say that, my dog wears everything designer and I get all its clothes custom-made.


Natalya: Custom-made clothes do not ensure quality. Moreover, your dog is absolutely unhygienic.


Ivan: I have special maids appointed to get my dog cleaned everyday and I personally take care of its paw-nails.


Natalya: If so was the case, your dog wouldn’t have left his paw prints when it entered my lounge.


OR


(B)


In the two stories, both needed help but the nature of help needed and received was way different. In The Black Aeroplane, the pilot is helped by a stranger in a black aeroplane in the storm, without lights who helps him steer through the dark clouds. However, when the pilot reached the base, he was told that there was no other aeroplane in the air other than his. Thus, he doesn’t get to know who helped him. In this story the pilot did not ask for help and yet he received it and he is thus, thankful for it. On the other hand, in A Letter to God, a different nature of aid is received by Lencho when he writes a letter to God asking for money. His conviction in God touches the postmaster and he raises money for Lencho and sends it to him. In this story, Lencho asks for help and the source of his aid is clearly revealed, yet he is not satisfied and instead blames his helpers of robbing him.


More from this chapter

All 13 →
9

Attempt ANY ONE of the following in 100-120 words. (5 marks)

(A) The chart below displays data about the number of digital devices purchased in Rishunagar across the years 2015-2019. Write a paragraph analyzing the given data.






OR


(B) Read the following excerpt from an article that appeared in the magazine section of a local daily:


The ban on single-use plastic is impractical. The purpose of articles like bags and packaging is ultimately to make human life easier. Plastic articles do this well, so they shouldn’t be banned.






Write a paragraph to analyse the given argument.


You could think about what alternative explanations might weaken the given conclusion and include rationale / evidence that would strengthen / counter the given argument.



 10

Answer ANY TWO questions in 20-30 words each, from (A) and (B) respectively.

(A) (any two)


i. How did Peggy justify her cruel behavior towards Wanda?


ii. Describe how Custard’s reaction was different from that of others, on seeing the pirate?


iii. Who, according to Nelson Mandela, is a courageous man?


(B) (any two)


i. Why did Oliver Lutkin’s mother laugh as she chased him and Bill away?


ii. Why was it important for Mrs. Pumphrey to be a little cruel in order to be kind towards Tricki?


iii. List any one characteristic of Bholi’s teacher with reference to her first day at school. Give a reason for your answer.


 1

Answer ANY TWO questions in 40-50 words each, from (A) and (B) respectively.

(A) (any two)


i. Annie writes that it was fortunate that Mr. Keesing took the joke the right way. Why does she feel so?


ii. The use of symbolism in the poem ‘Fire and Ice’ conveys the poet’s message effectively. Expand with reference to thepoem.


iii. Justify the poet’s allusion to Rapunzel in ‘Amanda’.


(B) (any two)


i. Griffin’s brilliance as a man of science fades before his darker traits. Comment.


ii. Why do you think Mr. Weiherer was pleased that Richard Ebright not only put in the nightly research hours towards butterflies, but also his other interests?


iii. What mademe Forestier exclaim in astonishment, when she saw Matilda, years after the Minister’s ball?


 1

Answer ANY ONE of the following in 100-120 words.

(A) Hari Singh says- “He knew it but neither his lips nor his eyes showed anything.”


Anil successfully addressed the situation by not addressing it at all. Elaborate based on your reading of The Thief’s Story.


OR


(B) Read the following quote by an American author, E. E. Hale.


“I am only one but, I am one. I cannot do everything but I can do something. And I will not let what I cannot do interfere with what I do.”


Bholi’s evolution from a ‘dumb cow’ to a ‘masterpiece’ supports the given quote. Justify