Q24 of 25 Page 1

“Sociologist Satish Saberwal elaborates upon the modern context by sketching three aspects to the modern framework of change in colonial India.” Which three aspects are being talked about? Describe any two of them.

“Sociologist Satish Saberwal elaborates upon the modern context by sketching three aspects to the modern framework of change in colonial India.” These three aspects are – Modes of communication, Forms of organisation, and the nature of ideas.

Different modes of communication – The development of the new technology led to the increase in the emergence of the new forms of communication such as printing press, telegraph, and microphone, movement of goods and the people from one place to another through steamship and railways. There are numerous examples of this development in India, for example – social reformers from Punjab and Bengal exchanged their ideas with the reformers of the Madras and Maharashtra, in 1864 Keshav Chandra Sen of Bengal visited Madras, Pandita Ramabai travelled to different parts of the country. Also, some visited various other countries for example - Christian missionaries travelled to different corners present-day Nagaland, Mizoram and Meghalaya.


The nature of ideas – As the development took place new ideas began to emerge such as ideas of liberalism and freedom, homemaking and marriage, a self-conscious pride in culture and tradition and new roles for mothers and daughters. Education has become important; also for society and the country to become modern, but at the same time preserve its ancient heritage. The topic of female education was put forward strongly and discussed deeply. Reformers discussed that it is important for women to get an education for the progress of society. Social reformers Jotiba Phule opened the first school for women in Pune. Meaning of tradition and modernity was discussed deeply among them. Thus, the 19th century was the period of the questioning, reinterpretations, intellectual and social growth.


Various social reform movements have different ideas to be discussed such as problems that the upper caste, middle-class women and men faced. Other problems were related to the injustice faced due to indiscrimination and the emergence of social evils due to the decline of the true spirit of Hinduism. For some caste and gender discrimination was fundamental to religion. The meaning of polygamy and purdah was intensely discussed by the Muslim social reformers for example - Jahanara Shah Nawas at the All India Muslim Ladies Conference proposed a resolution against the evils of polygamy. This became the topic of debate in Muslim Press like the leading journal for women in Punjab, called Tahsib-e-Niswan stood in favour of this but others disapproved.


There were some ideas which became the theme of debate in the community also such as the Brahmo Samaj opposed the practice of Sati. An organisation called Dharma Sabha was formed by the orthodox community of Bengal and appealed against the British who argued that reformers had no right to interpret sacred texts.


More from this chapter

All 25 →
21

Evaluate the impact of the Bombay Mill Strike of 1982.

22

“Many tribal areas have had a rich tradition of grass root democratic functioning. However, these institutions weren’t necessarily democratic in their structure and functioning.” Comment.

OR


“Karachi Resolution reflects a vision of democracy.” Discuss.

23

“Is tribe part of the caste continuum”? Substantiate your answer with reasons.

25

From Stree Purush Tulana 1882…Who are these women you give such names to? Whose womb did you take your birth in? Who carried the killing burden of you for nine months? Who was the saint who made you the light in her eye, …How would you feel if someone said about your mother, “That old chap’s mother, you know, she’s a gateway to hell’. Or your sister, “That so-and so-s’ sister, she’s a real storehouse of deceit’. …Would you just sit and listen to their bad words?… …Then you get blessed with a bit of education and promoted to some important new office- and you start feeling ashamed of your first wife. Money works its influence on n you and you begin to say to yourself, what does a wife matter after all? Don’t we just give them a few rupees a month and keep them at home like any other servant, to do the cooking and look after the house? You begin to think of her like some female slave you’ve paid for….If one of your horses died it wouldn’t take long to replace it, and there’s no great labour needed to get another wife either. ..The problem is Yama hasn’t got time to carry off wives fast enough or you’d probably get through several different ones in one day!

a) Were social reform movements fought only by males? Give reasons for your answer.


b) Name any two women’s organisations.